The Disproportionate Impact of High-Potential Employees
High-potential employees (HiPOs) are the star performers who drive an organization forward. They represent a small portion of the workforce but contribute a significantly larger share of the work and effort. As Henry Ford is credited with saying, “The only thing worse than training your employees and having them leave is not training them and having them stay.” While most organizations seek great talent, not all commit the resources necessary for continuous development.
A study in Personnel Psychology titled, "Star Performers in Twenty-First Century Organizations," confirms this disparity. In alignment with the Pareto Principle, a small number of employees drive a large proportion of results:
- The top 1% accounts for 10% of organizational output.
- The top 5% accounts for 25% of organizational output.
- The top 20% accounts for 80% of organizational output.
Identifying these individuals is only half the battle. The other half is providing the nurturing, resources, and improvement opportunities required to realize their full impact.
How to Identify High-Potential Employees
While definitions can vary, a HiPO is generally understood as an employee who demonstrates significant contributions, embodies organizational values, and has the clear potential to take on greater responsibilities. The Employee Performance Nine-Box Talent Matrix offers a typical framework.
Some organizations get more specific, defining HiPOs as those able to advance two leadership levels within four to eight years. Whatever the exact criteria, these individuals consistently produce above-average results and possess a unique combination of qualities.
Key Indicators of High Potential
According to research highlighted in the Harvard Business Review, certain indicators can help spot high-potential talent. The first is a specific kind of motivation: a fierce commitment to excelling in pursuit of collective, unselfish goals, paired with deep personal humility.
Other critical qualities include:
- Past Performance: A demonstrated track record of success and initiative.
- Curiosity: A deep desire to understand how things work and a proactive approach to seeking feedback for self-improvement.
- Engagement: A persuasive personality that connects quickly and effectively with others.
- Determination: A persistent, focused drive to overcome obstacles and achieve goals.
- Insight: The ability to process information effectively and propose thoughtful alternatives.
Best Practices for Developing HiPOs and Early Talent
Once identified, HiPOs need specialized career development to ensure they can rise to their potential. Star performers know their value and will move to other organizations if they aren’t recognized, motivated, and challenged. They dislike stagnation and seek rewarding work that hones their talents.
Because HiPOs have already proven their work style is effective, development should focus on coaching rather than traditional training. Based on past Best Practice Institute studies, here are four effective methods for developing HiPOs:
-
Action Learning: Assign HiPOs, mentors, and teams to solve real-world business challenges. This approach uses both simulated and real-time issues relevant to the organization.
-
Learning Technology: Utilize synchronous and asynchronous tools like adaptive learning, virtual reality, and simulations to improve performance more efficiently than classroom training.
-
Stakeholder-Centered Executive Coaching: Involve stakeholders in a leader's development process. This method helps leaders understand diverse perspectives, reduce risk, and demonstrate measurable behavioral change over time.
-
Accountability Partnerships: Pair HiPOs with partners who support their development. Research shows that consistent, weekly follow-up with these partners yields the greatest amount of positive change.
Retaining Your High-Potential Talent
After identifying and developing early talent and HiPOs, an organization must focus on retention. These employees desire recognition for their potential and contributions. To retain them, it’s critical to reward them as much as possible through a combination of motivators. While salary is a key factor, being credited for contributing to the organization's overall success is equally important.