Understanding the 360-Degree Feedback Assessment
A 360-degree feedback report provides a comprehensive view of an individual's leadership behaviors by gathering anonymous feedback from multiple sources. It compares a self-assessment against perceptions from superiors, peers, and subordinates. This multi-faceted view is critical for identifying blind spots and creating a targeted plan for professional development.
Core Leadership Competencies
A robust 360-degree assessment measures specific, observable behaviors. These competencies define what effective leadership looks like within the organization. A sample framework might include:
- Vision: Communicating a long-term, "big picture" view that generates hope and excitement.
- Motivation: Creating passion and compelling people to follow through faith and trust.
- Courage: Being bold and innovative, inspiring trust with ideas that are not necessarily the safest.
- Teamplay: Evoking the best from a team by appreciating each member and fostering open communication.
- Sensei: Teaching and transferring knowledge, developing associates' strengths, and correcting weaknesses.
- Business Acumen: Leveraging experience, education, and resources to obtain results with a thirst for knowledge.
- Citizenship: Embodying integrity, humility, and service, acting as a model in business and civic life.
- Emotional Competency: Intuitively sensing others' feelings and motivations to manage and influence situations while maintaining self-awareness.
- Client Relationships: Identifying and developing strategic client and vendor relationships through quality service.
- Business Development: Using knowledge of the industry and market to develop and close new business.
Interpreting Assessment Feedback and Ratings
Once feedback is collected, the summary observations provide a narrative analysis of the data. A key goal is to examine the variance between different rater groups and the self-assessment.
Analyzing Rating Discrepancies
It is common for ratings from all assessors to be variable. A significant disconnect between your self-perception and how others see you is a critical area for reflection. For example, if you rate yourself at a level 4 ("Usually Demonstrated") but assessors rate you 1 to 3 levels lower, it indicates your leadership traits may be invisible to others or that your definition of a skill differs from their expectations.
Insights from Different Rater Groups
-
Subordinates: Subordinates' ratings can be particularly insightful. If they rate you lower than you rate yourself or lower than other groups, it may suggest they have a sophisticated understanding of leadership from their vantage point. It could also mean they haven’t had enough exposure to you to observe certain skills. This pattern often implies a leader may be better at "managing up" than managing their own team.
-
Peers and Superiors: The perceptions of peers and superiors are often more aligned with your own, but still typically lower than a self-rating. They provide a unique perspective on your effectiveness. Peers might see your greatest strength as "Courage," while superiors may value your "Client Relationships" most highly. These differences highlight which behaviors are most visible and valued by each group.
Translating Feedback into an Action Plan
Developmental feedback is designed to be actionable. The "Start, Stop, Continue" model is a simple yet powerful framework for organizing comments into a personal learning contract.
Start Doing
This category identifies new behaviors to adopt for improved effectiveness. Feedback may point to a need to improve specific skills or shift focus.
- Example Feedback: Be more direct in communications with superiors; find more opportunities to transfer knowledge to the next generation; focus more on managing deliverables and less on contributing to them.
Continue Doing
This feedback affirms what you are doing well and should maintain. These are your perceived strengths and positive contributions that you should continue to leverage.
- Example Feedback: Maintain a calm demeanor in the face of adversity; encourage the team to think "out of the box"; continue building client relationships and confidence.
Stop Doing
These are behaviors or habits that may be hindering your effectiveness or negatively impacting the team. Addressing these can unlock significant growth.
- Example Feedback: Stop avoiding necessary conflict; stop taking issues and problems personally; stop sharing associate confidences or venting personal issues to subordinate staff.
By comparing your own priorities with the recommendations from your assessors, you can create a well-rounded and impactful development plan focused on the behaviors that matter most.